Showing posts with label Cooperative Agreements. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cooperative Agreements. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 24, 2016

Questions for NAMB, IMB, and seminary leaders

One feature of the annual meeting of our beloved Southern Baptist Convention is a time for reports from entity heads. These leaders usually leave a short time for questions from the floor. While I'm not planning to be in muggy St. Louis next month, if I were and could stake out one of the floor mics here's a question or two that I'd like to ask:

For David Platt, International Mission Board leader:

The locations of our overseas personnel has shifted over the past years to a greater proportion being in World A locations. I presume that these are more difficult and stressful places and would like to know some things about attrition rates:

  1. What is the attrition rate for our career personnel after 5 years, 10 years?
  2. Is there a difference in rates in World A countries and other locations?
  3. What is the IMB doing to reduce these rates?
  4. Has the IMB found that certain measures or methods of support from the home churches of personnel have reduced attrition rates.
What is the average cost of a career missions couple (single) from initial contact with IMB through appointment and the end of the first full term?

For Kevin Ezell, North American Mission Board leader:

NAMB uses "Strategic Cooperative Agreements" and "Strategic Cooperative Budgets" with state conventions to spell out joint work and funding for such work. Given that all of NAMB's funding comes from the churches and individuals, what is the reasoning behind the policy that these agreements not public information to Southern Baptists?

NAMB has been criticized for being heavy-handed in it's relationship with some of the non-southern states where NAMB provides much or most funding for many personnel. Why would it not be preferable to distribute funds to these state conventions as grants not tied to specific positions or goals and let local staff utilize them as they think best?

For Albert Mohler, president of Southern Baptist Theological Seminary and Danny Akin, president of Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary:

SBC presidential candidate Steve Gaines is quoted as saying, "Calvinism does not need to be taught as the exclusive, optimal theological viewpoint in our seminaries. Non-Calvinist students should not be subjected to Calvinistic professors who proactively seek to convert them to Calvinism. None of our seminaries should have a faculty of professors who are exclusively Calvinistic. Non-Calvinistic professors should be an integral part of each one of our seminary faculties because most Southern Baptists are not Calvinists, and they are the ones that fund our seminaries and pay the salaries of our professors."

Although Gaines did not name SBTS and SEBTS, others have made accusations about your two seminaries doing that to which Gaines objects. Are non-Calvinist students subjected to proactive conversion efforts by professors in your seminaries and does your faculty include non-Calvinistic professors?
___________________________
On the questions for Platt, I don't know the answers and don't know that I've ever seen material published by IMB or by missiologists in our seminaries who have been given IMB data on which they have done research. This is perhaps the most critical personnel issue for IMB and I'd like to see these rates.

On the questions for Ezell, he has an article that generally explains the agreements and the reason they are not public. While I have an idea about the second question, being the troublemaker that I am, I'd just like to see how much explanation he would give.

On the questions for Al Mohler and Danny Akin, Gaines has laid down a marker by raising the questions and making specific demands. I don't disagree with him at all. He didn't name names but others have and have named SBTS and SEBTS. I'd like to seen Mohler and Akin have a chance to respond. Akin has responded specifically to such things in the past.

Of course, no one will ask these questions and there's not enough time to fully treat the subjects anyway. But, when Southern Baptists have questions, it's always good for our leaders to give answers. If this convention is like any of the couple of dozen I've attended, a lot of floor time will be expended on subjects much more trivial than these.

I trust that my SBC convention-going colleagues will have a grand time in St. Louis.



Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Assault on the good old Cooperative Program about to be launched?

Hear anything much about the SBC name change recommendation lately?

Nope. Not too much.

Apparently, SBCers are pretty much squawked out on that. We will vote next month on the informal, non-mandatory, optional, if-you-wanna-but-we're-not-forcing-you-to-use-it descriptor. It will pass easily with moderate opposition...and then we will eat beignets and forget it.

The SBC issue-of-the-year is the "tension" between our North American Mission Board and the state conventions. That would be some state conventions, mainly those for whom NAMB has cut their entitlements (Jerry Rankin's choice of words).

Baptist Press has a story that explains things a bit. I have a few articles on it.

Hmmm, seems I hear some rumblings about states offering churches a way to designate around NAMB and keep their Cooperative Program money close to home. Perhaps it is just chest thumping and venting rather than a serious discussion. I hope so; however, the CP is already our most seriously declining metric and we absolutely shouldn't be kicking it farther down which is what anything like this would do.

It would be ironic indeed for state conventions to lead the way in undermining the Cooperative Program just to keep some of their personnel on the payroll.

Nah...they wouldn't do that, would they?

It's one thing for individual churches to designate. It's another thing for states assist and encourage churches to do so. In the past the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship was powerful enough in some states to do this. I don't think the results have been helpful. We don't need to try that again, and that among our conservative selves.

I would think that a responsible state convention executive would be the first to say, "No fellows. We are not going this route. We've promoted the Cooperative Program all these decades. It is a great cooperative giving plan and we're not going to dismantle it because we have current issues with one SBC entity. We will work it out another way."

One association here in Georgia passed a resolution that suggested that churches take a chunk (25-35 percent) out of their Cooperative Program giving and give it instead to "state missions." This is probably just frustration and venting but I'd hope that our state CEO would respond quickly if the resolution is directed to him. (I will probably take that resolution up in a blog in a few days. It is interesting.) 

"Great Commission Giving" is the culprit, some say? Not really, though I haven't seen data on how churches are reporting in this new giving category yet.

GCG might have been like throwing a teaspoon full of kerosene on a fire. States promoting CP designations would be like tossing a tanker load of jet fuel on it. We might all get burned up in that.


Friday, April 27, 2012

NAMB funding to state conventions: "Entitlements"?

I don’t know of any Southern Baptist who can speak about missions with more credibility than Jerry Rankin, immediate past president of the International Mission Board. 
Rankin wrote a blog article on the North American Mission Board yesterday:


Here’s a portion of it:
For years [NAMB] has been a conduit of funding for state conventions; partnership agreements channeling their work through these and other entities have left little margin for initiative and resources to take the gospel to underserved and neglected areas. Meanwhile baptisms have continued to decline and church growth has stagnated outside the Bible belt…


…It is understandable that there would be denominational leaders disagreeing with changes in strategy and priority; after all it means reductions in subsidies and elimination of effective programs and staff fulfilling significant roles.  

Collectively and cooperatively we can have the resources and resolve to make a difference, but not if the priority is to continue traditions and maintain the status quo. Why should NAMB’s strategy and resources be funneled to state programs in the Bible Belt that already receive the bulk of Cooperative Program funding and are where there is the  greatest concentration of established churches in the world.



Certainly there are still vast swatches of lostness, needs for ministry and areas new churches need to be planted everywhere, but should not churches in those states take more responsibility for the mission where they are located and free NAMB to represent us in areas that have a dearth of churches and  minuscule resources? No one likes to give up entitlements, but if we truly have a heart for reaching the lost everyone should be willing to make sacrifices in their own programs to get it done.

One notices that he used the term “entitlements” in a context that questions NAMB’s legacy practice of “funnel[ing]…state programs in the Bible Belt”.

“Entitlements” you say, Jerry? That’s a pretty strong term, and not particularly positive either.

Those who are paying attention, an admittedly small slice of Southern Baptists, are aware that a number of state convention leaders are doing some fairly serious complaining, something SBCers consider a God-given right, about changes at NAMB that affect their budgets. These executives, one presumes, are complaining even more loudly in private than they are in public.

The complaints stem from changes in funding formulas and policies. NAMB’s critics may speak of such things in terms of how the organization has dictated changes, how they have been heavy handed, or how historic cooperative relationships have been discarded. 

None of this language for Jerry Rankin. Read the whole piece. 

It is infused with frank terminology like “subsidies,” “continue[ing] traditions,” “self-interest,” “provincialism,” "status quo," and, yes, “entitlements.”

Ouch...but I cannot say that each of those terms are accurate.

Tuesday, April 10, 2012

So, how do we expect NAMB to spend our money?

The North American Mission Board is Southern Baptists' second largest entity with a budget for 2012 of $115 million. NAMB gets the second largest slice of Cooperative Program money, about ten percent. Their annual mission offering, the Annie Armstrong Easter Offering for North American Missions, totaled over $56 million in 2011.

One wonders, just how do we expect NAMB to spend our money?

Were Southern Baptists satisfied with the spending under prior administrations which included overseas trips to movie premiers, ice sculptures for in house events, and millions in wasted money on programs now defunct?

Were Southern Baptists satisfied with centralizing spending in NAMB's Alpharetta headquarters with hundreds of employees and paying millions in travel expenses?

Were Southern Baptists satisfied that NAMB in reaching North America for Christ, was spending only about twenty-eight cents on every budgetary dollar on church planting?

Are Southern Baptists displeased that headquarters employment and spending and travel expenses have been cut by many millions and that spending on church planting will consume forty-two cents on every 2012 budgetary dollar?

I hear a lot of general complaining about NAMB but I'd like to hear someone make the case made for the status quo ante at NAMB.

Aha, it's about NAMB cutting funding to state conventions some say.

Fair enough. Can we talk data?

NAMB no longer pays insurance for positions they fund at less than a 50% level (although I understand that for some of these they have agreed to take several years to transition the ending of that funding). There are several positions that NAMB funds at a very insignificant sum, couple of hundred dollars a month, for which they have paid 100% of insurance costs.

Does anyone think it inappropriate that this system be ended?

NAMB has a policy that is reducing cooperative funding to the stronger state conventions and increasing funding in the weaker state conventions.

Do Southern Baptists think this is unwise or unfair?

A commenter here made the assertion that NAMB is "decimating" missions in  the Colorado Baptist General Convention.

Really?

Well, not really, if funding is any measure of things, since NAMB has increased funding to Colorado by about one third for 2012. Other states may wish for NAMB to decimate missions in their state in this manner.

A popular blogger from New Mexico lamented NAMB's cutting of mission funding for his state.

Really?

Well, really. NAMB has dropped their funding for New Mexico by about $222,000 for 2012, about a twenty percent cut.

Why?

Seems New Mexico is a pretty strong Southern Baptist state with well over 300 congregations serving a total population of right at two million. In fact, the case can be made from the data that New Mexico is a stronger Southern Baptist state than even Florida and than every other state outside the South except for Wyoming. NAMB has adjusted their funding based on parameters that make sense to me, although making sense isn't always the measure in SBC funding issues.

I wish someone would make the case for NAMB spending our money differently and in doing so specifically address all of the above.

I've seen Kevin Ezell and, to make a wild conjecture, he doesn't look like he can walk on water. I suppose he has made some mistakes at NAMB and perhaps some of the new NAMB policies are not wise, not workable, or appropriate.

Would some insightful SBCer please make the case for how NAMB can better spend our money.

The field for doing so is wide open. Have at it.



Monday, April 2, 2012

Why all this complaining about NAMB?



For those who like ecclesiastical drama you cannot beat our North American Mission Board. They have provided Southern Baptists with at least two major train wrecks in the last six years. But, alas, train wrecks are expensive and I’d forego them in favor of an organization that is effective in reaching North America for Christ. Thankfully, NAMB seems to be back on track absent the kind of dysfunctional behavior to which we had grown accustomed.

The new NAMB has declared an intention to spend half of their budget on church planting and to get there they have cut HQ personnel, travel expenses, and are redirecting the part of their budget that recycled funds back to state conventions.

Who would complain about that?

Well, some state conventions executives would, which is why state convention executives have  appointed a special committee of state CEOs to “evaluate relations” between NAMB and state conventions.

Fair enough, autonomous Baptist bodies exercising their cherished autonomy.

How about we consider the Arkansas Baptist State Convention as an example. There are about 1500 churches and half a million members in the convention. Churches there took in a bit under $350 million in 2010. 

NAMB kicks back about $425,000 to the ABSC for various causes. The ABSC leader, Emil Turner, says that figure is so small that its impact is “minimal.” Apparently, it’s not too minimal for him to complain about the cost and about the loss of it.

You can read Turner’s recent comments on NAMB here .

If there are that many churches with that much money Arkansas, one wonders exactly why NAMB is funneling back ANY dollars to that state, or to Georgia, Alabama or other strong SBC state conventions?

Evidently it is done because the states are accustomed to some NAMB gravy being ladled out from Alpharetta and don’t like the idea of it being reduced or eliminated.

In Baptist life sticks and stones may break bones but what really gets folks riled up is to cut their funding, minimal though it may be.

A little quiz here brethren/sistren. Which of the following are complaints about NAMB?

a) NAMB funds only about one-third of the cost of missionaries in Arkansas.

b) NAMB plans to cut funds for the health insurance of those missionaries for which which NAMB pays less than half the cost.

c) Arkansas receives less NAMB funding than almost every other state convention.

d) NAMB is going to make changes that will hurt the ASBC in the future.

e) NAMB is severely hurting their [state convention] partners.

f) NAMB's financial impact on Arkansas is "minimal."

g) NAMB's funding is "Incredibly complicated."

h) To get NAMB's minimal funding, the ASBC has to spend twice the dollars.

i) NAMB is missing a "serious evangelism stragegy."
j) NAMB "strategy for planting churches does not guarantee that churches that are planted will be marked by Baptist distinctives."

Well, how about ALL of the above? And one notes that all of them save for the last two concern money, which means that at least in Arkansas all of the complaints about NAMB can be solved if the state convention takes charge of funding missionaries in their own strong, heavily churched state.

And, really, if it is minimal, if NAMB funds don't even figure into their budget, and if it is incredibly complicated, and costs Arkansas so much of their own money why wouldn't they fund their own stuff and stop all this complaining?

Why not pick up the phone, call Kevin Ezell, and say "Kevin, we love you man but why don't you keep your $425k and put it in Maine or Montana. Where there aren't so many SBC churches?

Why not indeed.

Arkansas has 1500 churches in a state with less than 3 million people.  The Baptist Convention of New England has about one-sixth the numbers of churches serving five times the population. Maybe those states would be a more sensible destination for the lousy $425,000 that is so minimal in Arkansas.

I have no quarrel with Arkansas or its leaders. My state, Georgia, gets the same type of funding from NAMB. I would note that in Arkansas   Cooperative Program giving from churches is increasing. In Georgia, they are dropping like a rock. So, who do you think would be the more likely state convention executive to complain about NAMB?

Go figure.

NAMB still falls short of the glory of God. They still have some things going on that should be scrutinized but on this kickback funding to the states, I think they are on the right track.


Friday, February 24, 2012

NAMB in the bullseye


In the old days, hapless seminary students learning greek would be required to look at a New Testament verse in their Greek New Testament and parse the words - masculine, singular, nominative, whatever. Ah,the memories.

Now it's all done for you, clickable on innumerable internet sites. Alas, I was born a couple of decades too soon.

Here's something to parse, though, that isn't done for you:  

State execs form NAMB study committee
State convention executive directors have appointed a special committee to evaluate relations with the North America Mission Board.
Uh oh.
May I select a few quotes for my dear readers to parse:
Emil Turner, executive director of the Arkansas Baptist State Convention and president of the fellowship for 2011-12, said the committee was established "to evaluate how state conventions and NAMB can maximize cooperation during the transition process of implementing the new NAMB initiatives."

Members of the committee are David Hankins, chairman, executive director of the Louisiana Baptist Convention...
This wouldn't be the same Emil Turner and David Hankins who notably, publicly, and loudly said when the present head of NAMB was to be voted on by trustees that "Southern Baptists who want to lead a denominational entity “ought to have a track record of supporting those entities.”
Well...I suppose it was the same two.
Turner said the NAMB study committee is important to evaluating and understanding the future work of state conventions with NAMB.

"Evaluating" and "understanding" beg for parsing here.
Following the establishment of the committee, Turner said he contacted Ezell to reassure him the action "is not to be or do anything adversarial, but to seek understanding and cooperation."

You bet. A calming phone call should always be given to someone who might think some action could possibly be interpreted as adversarial but really isn't because you got that congenial phone call.
Mike Ebert, NAMB's vice president of communications, said it is NAMB's "desire to be good partners with our state conventions," adding, "[We] are always open to anything that would move us toward penetrating lostness in North America. We are ultimately accountable to the Southern Baptist Convention through the NAMB trustees, and we are confident in the direction in which we are moving."

 NAMB's spokesman pointedly speaks such that when NAMB and accountability appear in the same sentence, state conventions receive no mention. 

I'd call that a shot across the bow.

State convention executives had a pretty tough year last year. The Georgia Baptist Convention let a bunch of people go because revenues were down by millions. Other state conventions have been feeling the pinch also.

I doubt any of them are in a mode to promote any increase for NAMB and are in crisis management mode to try and deflect any further cuts of the bouncebacks in funds NAMB has been giving to the states through those mysterious Cooperative Agreements. (I call them mysterious because I've never seen one, cannot get my hands on one, and have been refused permission to view them. If any of my dear readers happens to have a copy, I'd love to see it.)

Kevin Ezell already has the hardest job in the SBC. Looks like this year will be a bit tougher. 

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Seventeen reasons the Cooperative Program has been dropping like a rock - Part One

My humble conjectures about the decline of the once mighty Cooperative Program. Every Southern Baptist is a denominational pundit. Plodder's punditry, not in order of magnitude or importance:

1. It’s the moderates’ fault. Sure, SBC moderates were generally very strong givers to the cooperative program and were incessant promoters of it, so much so that they were willing to overlook almost anything so long as the CP was revered. Moderates made the CP into an end unto itself, rather than to means to the end. What pastor who wants to see souls saved, churches planted, and believers growing in Christ wants to subsume all this to support of a denominational giving plan?

Two words: Sacred Cow, only once the mods lost control of the cow, it suddenly became profane and they quickly deserted it. The dollars they once gave to the CP went elsewhere. Once it wasn’t their Sacred Cow, they acted like conservatives and eschewed it.

2. It’s the conservatives’ fault. This one is quite simple. Most of the high profile conservative, megachurch pastors gave only token support to the Cooperative Program and were not willing to give their money to SBC moderates who were in control of the convention’s machinery. Well, we fixed the latter but without fixing the former. Over three decades later, the SBC CP average is headed towards the giving pattern of those early Conservative Resurgence mega-pastors. Conservatives never got on board of the CP.

It’s also the conservatives fault in that there is no reward for very high CP givers anymore. Give 15% and get waxed in an election by a pastor of a church who gives less than 4%. Want to be a trustee? Don’t worry about giving 10% or more, just give 5%, maybe less, and you’ll be OK.

3. It’s the megachurch pastors’ fault. Megachurches are a denomination unto themselves, so, they think, ‘Why give much to a state convention, seminaries, and mission boards through the CP when we can do it all alone?’ Too many micro-pastors think the megas walk on water and should be emulated; hence, lower CP percentages. Good enough for Rogers, Stanley, Smith, et al…good enough for Joe Schmoe pastor of Crossroads MicroBaptist Church.

4. It’s the boomers, baby busters, Xers, and millenials fault. Less denominational loyalty, more personal debt. Not impressed with big institutions. More hands-on, etc. General demographic trends...stuff we've been fed by the experts for years. I’d speculate that this factor, which has nothing to do with SBC politics, should be heavily weighted in this list.

5. It’s the fault of various parachurches. AWANA, independent mission sending organizations, et al sucked up local church dollars and diluted the SBC brand in a church.

6. It’s the fault of Bold Mission Thrust. Huh? I mean by this that a component BMT was volunteer missions and that was one of the few goals of BMT that was far exceeded. Churches felt like if they had their own people who needed help in going overseas, why give to nameless, faceless missionaries through the CP?

7. It’s the fault of the denominational culture of secrecy and opaqueness. Want to see one of NAMB’s Cooperative Agreements with your state convention? Sorry, you can’t. Want to know how much CP funds were paid in severance to a leader forced to resign? Sorry, it may be your money but you don’t get to see this. If CP spending is hidden, SBCers are less likely to want to keep shoveling money into that dark hole. “Trust the Lord and tell the people” we used to say. Now it is “Take the money and tell the people to shut up.”

8. NAMB's recent history of magnificent debacles. No further explanation needed for this one.


Almost every Southern Baptist who reads this, pastor or layperson, will be in a church whose CP percentage has dropped over the past 30 years. I would be curious as to which of these (or others that I haven’t thought about) would you say is the cause.

Part Two tomorrow.

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Ma NAMB's unveils new strategy, new terminology

Kevin Ezell, as promised, unveiled his new strategy to NAMB trustees yesterday. As expected, they approved all of it.

Baptist Press report on it: NAMB trustees approve sweeping changes

Is it fair to ask if one aspect of the new strategy is more than a fresh coat of paint on the old barn. I'm speaking of the NAMB/State convention relationships, the so-called "Cooperative Agreements."

There was great anguish along with loud weeping and wailing from some state conventions when the Great Commission Task Force said that NAMB needed to control how they spend their budget and to get greater control they should phase out these Cooperative Agreements with state conventions.

These are being phased out but are being replaced by what Ezell describes as "integrated strategic partnership agreements" with states. This is Baptist Press' quote. I presume that Ezell said the words.

"Integrated strategic partnership agreements" certainly sounds sexier than "Cooperative Agreements." Is there a difference other than the title? I dunno. Ezell did say this about NAMB pouring money into the states under these agreements:

As NAMB funding to Southern states is reduced, Ezell said state leaders will be able to direct that money to specific unreached regions of their choosing. NAMB activity in the South will continue, Ezell said, noting, "We'd be very remiss if we did not continue to invest in the South and plant churches in those areas."
And will ordinary Southern Baptists, you know, the ones who pay all the bills through Cooperative Program and Annie Armstrong giving, be able to actually read one of these Integrated Strategic Partnership Agreements? If not, why not? It's our money.

And as expected, the trustees approved the five Baby NAMBs, regions that get their own layer of management - a Vice President, and attendant accoutrements.

Perhaps good things, good days, and productive ecclesiastical activity are about to begin at NAMB. I hope so. But Kevin Ezell, all of the NAMB executive level employees, and every single trustee should be required to regularly review a synopsis of NAMB's last five years of mistakes, meltdowns, and messes and be reminded how the organization let Southern Baptists down, wasted millions, and lost a lot of trust and credibility. Maybe this will motivate them to be diligent about the Lord's work, responsible in spending our money, and humble and grateful for the many millions that are entrusted to them.

I'm all for sounding the old standby clarion call of Southern Baptists: Let's Move On! Please, let's do. But let's not fail to learn from the recent past so that we do not repeat those expensive mistakes.

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Ma NAMB and now five Baby NAMBS


No big surprise here. The mostly megachurch people on the Great Commission Task Force called for decentralization of NAMB so now we have Ma NAMB and five baby NAMBs.

While I understand the concept of getting people out of Alpharetta and into the hinterlands, it remains to be seen if this is better or just different. The 25% reduction in HQ personnel should free up plenty of money to add the five new VPs and whatever attendant costs that come with them - buildings, assistants, clerical help, travel.

Will the new VPs be primarily used for fund dispersement and reporting? Or, what?

Is the expectation that they will be better at starting churches than state convention executives? Why?

How will the Baby NAMBs be different than the present arrangement with state conventions?

Ezell speaks of "working in close partnership with state Southern Baptist conventions", though, presumably, without the present Cooperative Agreements. So, we will have new agreements under different terminology? It's difficult for me to envision NAMB directly planting churches in, say, New England without involvement of the Baptist Convention of New England and any local association. Perhaps the details will be shared in next week's trustee meeting.

NAMB needs some success and no one is arguing that the status quo with NAMB was satisfactory.

Will having a NAMB VP on the ground in Chicago, Las Vegas, or Edmonton will translate into more churches? I don't know.

Guess we will find out.

Monday, August 30, 2010

What SBCers cannot see: NAMB/state Cooperative Agreements

Need some help sleeping? I'm happy to provide such assistance today.

Our North American Mission Board’s contracts with the individual Baptist state conventions, the “Cooperative Agreements,” are strictly inside SBC baseball and would be of little interest to most SBC pastors and all but the most engaged SBC laypeople except for the fact that they involve millions of dollars and except for the prominence given these contracts in the Great Commission Resurgence Report.

The Report adopted by the SBC in annual session in June recommended that these agreements be phased out.

I don’t have much hope that anything I report or any comment I make on this arcane business will be of much interest…but here is what little I have.

I have a copy of NAMB’s “generic” Cooperative Agreement. It is about 4 pages long and has language about Strategic Mission Plans, personnel policies, cooperation, etc. etc. It is saturated with good old fashioned Baptist bureaucratese. I don’t doubt that it is a necessary written contract between NAMB and the conventions.

I asked for a copy of our Georgia Baptist Convention/NAMB Cooperative Agreement. They wouldn’t let me have it, since it “involves personnel and…there are issues related to confidentiality that prohibit it from being shared” and "the...document does not belong to the [GBC]" and "remains in NAMB's possession." Can't say that I quite get that, but that's what I was told.

The NAMB/GBCdocument is 50 pages long and, sorry, I don’t buy the explanation that there are "issues" that preclude me and other ordinary SBCers from seeing it. Baloney. It is confidential not because it has to be, is required to be, or lack of such would be harmful if we got to see it. It is confidential because some SBC leader wanted it to be confidential. Bad policy, but typical in the SBC these days.

Our GBC people were polite and as helpful as they could be with the constraints they feel. I didn’t push it. The GBC has explained, generally, with some specifics, what NAMB’s money is used for here in our state: some GBC staff people, some associational staff people, some in-state training for churches and individuals, conferences, etc. etc. No, I don't have suspicions of gross waste and frivolous spending. I'd just like to see it for myself.

The GBC has indicated that they will try and absorb the $835k in NAMB money that would be lost in accord with the gradual phase-out of the NAMB funding. With Georgia having about 3300 SBC churches, 92 associations, and over a billion dollars in receipts, I don’t know why we should expect to get nearly a million dollars back from NAMB. I appreciate our CEO, Robert White and his leadership in this.

I would, however, still like to see the 50 page Cooperative Agreement between NAMB and the GBC and know of no persuasive reason why I should not be able to bore myself to death reading the thing should I so choose.

Unless the tooth fairy leaves it under my pillow, I guess I’ll never get the chance.