Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 22, 2012

The alternative universe of some evangelicals

I understand and value the fact that believers are citizens of heaven but wonder sometimes if some of the brethren and sistren spend too much time and thought in an alternative universe where the bizarre is normal,  the outlandish is true, and facts need not apply.

The country has Todd Akin, Missouri Republican senatorial candidate, to thank for a glimpse into that alternative universe. His comments on "legitimate rape" and on how a "the female body has ways to try to shut that whole [conception] thing down" have made him a household name.

Oh my.

I have heard both of these things in conservative Baptist circles for decades, especially the latter. If one values life, all life, even that of a child conceived as a result of rape, then it is quite natural seek an approach to the idea that the state should require rape victims to carry the child and give birth.

Most of our fellow citizens are repelled by such laws. I do not foresee the political stars aligning, ever, on such laws ever being passed.

What's a pro-life purist to do?

See Todd Akin. He posits that (a) some rape is not legitimate, and (b) that there are very, very few conceptions as a result of legitimate rape so we should not be too concerned about that.

Could we have the data behind the "shutting down" thing, please? I've heard that for years offered as an ex cathedra statement. 

And, legitimate and illegitimate rapes? This would be the belief that  if the state attempted to prohibit abortion save for the exceptions of health of the mother and rape then numbers of women would lie and claim rape to end a pregnancy. How the state would sort through such things should be pondered. In Todd Akin's America would such a woman be put on trial or  investigated to see if she really was legitimately raped and allowed to have that abortion?


But, in an alternative universe, who needs data driven facts and who needs to worry about the details of public policy implementation?

But Todd Akin's problem moves, I hate to say it, from the foolish ("stupidity" as Charles Krauthammer and others put it) to the unethical. His explanation and apology which included the usual 'I misspoke' and 'used the wrong words' belie what he actually said. He didn't just foul up the syntax and vocabulary and his backtracking is simply not credible.

Aside from what abortion policy support we want from candidates, do the people of Missouri want a candidate who does not own up to his own words and who offers the usual attempt at political doubletalk?

Also dwelling in the alternative evangelical universe are David Barton, now in freefall, and some young earth creationists but unlike the rape comment these are secondary issues. If one selectively quotes Jefferson or believes that dinosaurs coexisted with humans, a la the Flintstones, no lives are lost, no freedoms are lost.

...all of which is why the idea of political salvation is foolish and futile and that Christians who are pursuing such with gusts are chasing a chimera.

We should have learned better after a generation and a half of the hyper-politicalization of religious conservatives, with precious few results.

In contrast, there are no flaws in the Gospel, no need to finesse the truth, and individual changed lives are the surest way to achieve a better citizenry. 

My hope is built on nothing less than Jesus' blood and righteousness

Tuesday, October 25, 2011

What Many SBC Pastors Cannot Say

Ed Stetzer puts his finger on it in his blog, Why I Have No Difficulty Helping "Issue Christians" to Move On.

What most pastors cannot say is that sentence that burns a bridge with a prospective or present church member:
Our church probably isn't the place for you.
Stetzer describes a visitor to his church who started talking prophecy and Israel on his way through the receiving line after worship one Sunday. After a few minutes he had heard enough and said, "We are not one of those churches that you would think talks about prophecy enough-- this would not be the right church for you, but I do hope your search for a church home goes well."

Gold star for Stetzer.

Many pastors cannot train their lips to say such a thing and lose a member, a family, or a group of people from their church. It is almost one of those things not done. After all, aren't 80% or so of SBC pastors in churches that are plateaued or declining? Do we really want to run folks off?

Yes, indeed, if we know what's good for us and for our churches.

I think I am a decent listener. I don't mind listening to single issue people, or obsessed people, or folks who have an intense interest in something that I am ambivalent about. But I also know that if I play with a hand grenade it will eventually explode and hurt me.

Over the years I run across people whose interest was focused on American foreign policy with regard to Israel, with homeschoolers, with national politics and policy issues, with charismatic gifts, with the eschatological positions, with abortion and other things.

While all of these are important (e.g. we are against abortion but don't feel compelled to picket abortion clinics, a thrust of many 15 years ago), I understand that some are drawn to one of these with such a focus that all else is secondary and where those of us who do not share this intense interest are unspiritual or disobedient. Hogwash.

On occasion, I've said, "You probably will not be happy in this church." Better to get it out and be done with it.

Who knows how much grief I've avoided by training my lips to say such things. I highly recommend it.

[Postscript: I once had a young man come very early one Sunday, 30 minutes before Sunday School was to start, to ask me about doctrine. Early on in the conversation I could see that Calvinism was his, uh, intense interest and, while I might have enjoyed spending time with him on another occasion when I had the time, I just said, 'We're probably not the kind of church you would be happy in but come and worship with us this morning. We will welcome you.' He left and didn't come back.]

[Another postscript: Stetzer has a day job. Most of us do not. Would I be wrong to say that sending a prospective family down the road, with their tithes and faithful attendance, is a degree or two harder for us?]

Friday, July 1, 2011

Rick Perry playing evangelicals with prayer rally?

Rick Perry may run for president. I may vote for him if he does. He would be preferable to many of the GOP candidates and infinitely preferable to the present occupant of the White House.

But my radar is up on politicians who start marshalling the evangelical Christian vote and I'm getting a pretty strong reading on Perry. Not that other politicians aren't capable of the same but I just hate to get the feeling that evangelical Christians are just another voting bloc to be wooed, cajoled, and romanced into one politician's camp.

I started getting fwd:fwd:fwd emails last week about Perry's big prayer meeting - evangelical notables pumping 'our kind of guy' and all that. I'm all for prayer. I'm perfectly willing to grant the benefit of the doubt to him. I'm not questioning his sincerity in the prayer meetin'. Maybe it just looks like the governor has started to strum the evangelical strings as a prelude to declaring his candidacy.

There are critics. Some far more harsh than anyone quoted in this article: Perry's upcoming prayer event draws sharp criticism

So, this is merely Plodder pondering on the Perry prayer pow wow. Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe Perry, if he had thought of it, would have called for a mass prayer meeting back when Obamacare was passed, or when the Congress was furiously spending our grandchildren's trillions rather than when it's time to fish or cut bait on running for president in 2012.

Maybe the funny feeling I'm getting over this is too much sun, sugar, and cholesterol.

Hope so...

Monday, August 2, 2010

Who to vote for?

It’s about the time here in Georgia when political stuff gets interesting. We’ve had the party primaries and there are some runoffs in about a week. Whatever slight decorum and comity existed among the gaggle of candidates for various state offices, has been summarily jettisoned now that races are down to two individuals.

Here in GA, a candidate has to have a majority. None of this 40something percent winning an election in GA. Gotta have 50% plus one; hence, runoffs between the top two vote-getters in the primary.

The runoff for State Attorney General in the Republican primary is between a Jewish guy, a transplant from New Jersey no less, and a good old boy who has run in the past as a family-values, pro-Christian candidate. The Atlanta paper keeps us informed on the salient issues for the campaign.

Who should we pro-family, Christian, native Georgians vote for in this race?

Oh, seems that the pro-family guy has a record to run on somewhat beyond the community involvement, education, experience, previous offices blah, blah, blah. He has a divorce record that includes stuff like: extramarital affair with a college student (among others), infidelity, marital acrimony and the like. His record of serving as ‘faculty’ in a ministry that produces materials on good Christian morals for kids is not being trumpeted in the current campaign, nor is there any mention of family or Christian values in his campaign materials.

In his own words from the AJC article
“Without a doubt, I fell short in my personal life by getting a divorce, and people have the right to make a moral judgment on that if they chose."
He went on to say he still felt he was the best man to be Georgia's next attorney general.

Believe I’m voting for the Jewish guy from NJ. I can get used to the accent.

And for governor: One good old boy with the last name "Deal" whose first name should probably be "Sweet" on account of a business arrangement he had with the state that put millions in his and partner's pockets. Seems even the congressional ethics committee found some pungency in that.

His opponent is another transplant, a woman born in D.C. who grew up in MD. I'd call her a Yankee but Maryland is south of the Mason-Dixon line.

Newt likes the good old boy who has questionable ethics. Palin likes the female transplant.

Believe I'll go with the lady who has both good sense and good ethics.